ENGINEERS' INSIGHT

Hybrid Capacitors get the best of both worlds by combining Supercapacitor and Li-ion technology

Posted 18th January, 2017

Supercapacitors are commonly used wherever a quick energy boost is needed, as an alternative to a rechargeable battery. The most prevalent type of supercapacitors, EDLCs (electrical double layer capacitors), provide thousands or tens of thousands of times the capacitance of normal capacitors while their energy density makes them 10 times smaller than batteries (more here about how EDLCs work in detail). However, while EDLCs offer high capacitance, excellent power density and impressive efficiency, there are a few inherent properties which aren’t as desirable for some applications.

For example, most devices exhibit a characteristic called self-discharge, which means that if not discharged after a short time, the stored energy will leak away. The effect is particularly pronounced at high temperatures. Both leakage current and ESR (equivalent series resistance) can also exclude EDLCs from certain applications. The alternative, a secondary lithium ion (Li-ion) battery, offers higher energy density with reduced self-discharge, but they effectively wear out after a number of charge/discharge cycles. They also suffer from safety-related concerns such as thermal runaway, which can be catastrophic.

There is another device type on the market which combines the best features of EDLCs and Li-ion batteries. Called Li-ion capacitors, or hybrid capacitors, they are effectively a combination of the two technologies. While EDLCs hold energy using electrostatic charge, and Li-ion batteries use an electrochemical method, Li-ion capacitors use one electrostatic electrode and one electrochemical. The result is a device with better energy density than an EDLC, but without the self-discharge characteristic, and higher durability (more charge-discharge cycles) than a Li-ion battery, without the potential for dangerous thermal runaway.

Structure of a Hybrid Capacitor

The structure of a Li-ion capacitor or "Hybrid Capacitor"

Inside a Li-ion capacitor, the positive electrode is made of activated carbon. This is immersed in a liquid electrolyte (similar to the Li-ion salt solution used in batteries) together with the negative electrode, made of a carbon-based material doped with lithium ions. A separator prevents direct electrical contact. Pre-doping the negative electrode with lithium ions reduces its electrical potential, meaning a higher output voltage can be obtained without a high potential at the positive electrode, up to around 3.8V. Since the energy density is proportional to the square of this voltage, Li-ion capacitors are several times more energy dense than EDLCs, with a similar power density. What this means is the same amount of energy can be stored in a much more compact Li-ion capacitor than the equivalent EDLC, contributing to keeping device size small. The pre-doping also helps to stabilise the electrode’s potential, meaning there is very little self-discharge (see graph below). 

Li-ion capacitor voltage retention over time

Unlike EDLCs, Li-ion capacitors do not suffer from significant self-discharge

Compared to a Li-ion battery, in which the ions are inserted or extracted (intercalated or deintercalated) into the carbon lattice, ions in the Li-ion capacitor are simply adsorbed or desorbed on the electrode surface, there is no crystalline change taking place. This gives Li-ion capacitors a big advantage over batteries in terms of the number of charge/discharge cycles they can withstand, similar to the longevity of EDLCs. Li-ion capacitors also do not contain oxygen or oxides, so they are not prone to thermal runaway conditions. This makes them a safer alternative to Li-ion batteries. A full comparison table between the technologies is shown below. 

EDLC, Li-ion capacitor, and Li-ion battery comparison

Comparing the properties of EDLCs, Li-Ion capacitors and Li-ion batteries (LIBs)

As an example of some real-world devices, Avnet Abacus carries Li-ion capacitor parts from Taiyo Yuden between 40 and 270F (17.77 to 120 mAh) with an ESR as low as 0.05 Ω. These come in cylindrical metal casings and the smallest in the series is 35mm x 12.5mm. The operating temperature range is -25 to +70°C, but this can be extended to +85°C by reducing the operating voltage from 3.8 to 3.5V. A range of large capacitance devices is also under development – expected to cover the range 500 to 1000F (222 to 1420 mAh).

The different properties of EDLCs, Li-ion batteries and Li-ion capacitors suits each technology to various different applications. Li-ion capacitors are ideal for applications that demand high energy density, high power density, low leakage, longevity, durability and safety, as well as anywhere where the operating temperature is too high for efficient operation of EDLCs. This can include backup power sources for memory and other ICs, auxiliary power devices for energy-saving purposes (such as rapid drum heating in copiers and on start-up for projectors) and automotive electronics which are subject to harsh temperatures.

A key new application area for Li-ion capacitors is power supplies for energy harvesting devices, as they are quickly rechargeable, lightweight and don’t self-discharge. They can store the energy generated and produce it quickly when, say, wireless transmission is needed. Since they don’t wear out, the maintenance cost for changing coin cell batteries is eliminated. We expect to see many new types of small energy-harvesting applications enabled as a direct result of this exciting technology.  

If you are interested in Li-ion capacitor technology and would like to discuss your latest design requirements with one of our regional product specialists, click here to get in touch.

WRITTEN BY

Adam Chidley

Adam joined Avnet Abacus in 2006 as a Sales Consultant, moving into Product Management 18 months later. As European Senior Product Manager, Adam is responsible for key supplier relationships and marketing strategy for Avnet Abacus’ passive business unit.

RELATED ARTICLES

'Wet' vs. Polymer Aluminium Capacitors

Aluminium electrolytic and polymer wound aluminium electrolytic capacitors may seem similar at first glance, however the technologies offer very different performance characteristics.

Read More

Design Trends: Batteries for IoT

The Internet of things is opening up a whole new sphere of applications for electronic systems and selecting the right batteries for these systems can be tricky.

Read more

What's Super about Supercapacitors?

Supercapacitors are an alternative to using a battery or indeed the more common-or-garden variety of capacitor in many energy storage applications due to their many advantages.

Read More

Ask an Expert

Have a question? Our regional Product Specialists are on hand to help.

 

Get in touch